When a solvent company has passed its date of use and it does not
satisfy the criteria for deregistration then members’ voluntary winding up
(MVOL) is the only permitted way to dispose of such company.
There is no other viable alternative to the MVOL process in instances
where a company no longer has commercial use and where the members can gain some benefits by the company being
liquidated.
If your client’s company has ever conducted business in its own right or as the trustee of a trust then you should always consider MVOL rather than Deregistration as a matter of RISK management.
Benefits from member voluntary’s
winding up:
Tax Benefits:
One of
the main reasons to place a company into a Members Voluntary Liquidation is to
maximize the CGT concession benefits where there are proceeds from the sale of
a pre-CGT asset or where there are Small Business CGT concessions available.
The liquidator’s distribution of the company’s assets, represented by these
funds, is generally tax free and it may stay tax free in the hands of
shareholder(s) (Conditions apply).
If a company
has made payments out of the same funds to their shareholders
prior to winding up then these payments are generally deemed to be dividends (mostly probably unfranked).
There
are some other “side” benefits from MVOL which may in some circumstances be
valuable for your client’s company.
MVOL versus
Deregistration – A few pros and cons that should be considered
DEREGISTREATION:
- Deregistration is a simple, easy and cost effective process;
- On the date of the company’s deregistration with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC):-
- the company ceases to exist as a legal entity and can no longer do anything in its own right;
- deregistration with ASIC does not affect the company’s file with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO);
- the directors of the company immediately before deregistration must keep the company’s books and records in an accessible form (either printed or electronic):-
- for three (3) years) for the purpose of the Corporation Act 2001 (Act) (see SECT 601AD(5) of the Act – contravention of this section is an offence of strict liability);
- For five (5) years for the purpose of the Income Tax Administration Act 1936 (INCOME TAX ASSESSMENT ACT 1936 – SECT 262A );
- The company’s books and records must be made available for an audit for a prescribed time period to any of the statutory bodies if required.
- Number of aggrieved parties may request the ASIC to reinstate the deregistered company. Reinstating is a simple and cheap process which will restore a company as if it was never deregistered.
MEMBERS VOLUNTARY WINDING
UP:
- Members voluntary winding up is available only to solvent companies.
- MVOL is more complicated, time consuming and more costly than deregistration.
- The winding up of solvent companies must by
conducted according to the following legislations:-
- Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations)
(Schedule 2 of the Corporation Act 2001)
- Corporations Regulations 2001
- Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016
- Liquidator generally does not declare the
dividends unless he/she has not received the tax clearance for the company from
the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).
- When the ATO issues the tax clearance
for the company it effectively shuts down all of the company’s tax files.
- Where the liquidator distributes a particular
fund or account within the company’s books and records this distribution
maintains its character when being returned to the shareholder.
- All
available tax losses (if any) are utilised in the liquidator’s distribution.
- Liquidator’s payments made
during the liquidation process are generally referred to as dividends but they
are not all taxed as dividends for tax purposes.
- The liquidator’s
distribution of the company’s surplus assets represented by the Paid up
capital, Share premium reserve, Capital profit reserve (Pre-85) and Capital
profit reserve (Post-85 tax exempt) sourced from the available Small business
CGT concessions may stay free of tax (conditions apply) in the hand of the shareholder(s).
- Balance
of the franking credits can be utilised for the liquidator’s dividend to
members sourced from the company’s Income Profit reserve.
- ASIC deregisters the company automatically three
months from the date when the liquidator advises their office of finalisation
of liquidation.
- The company’s books and
records should be kept:-
- For the purpose of the Corporation Act 2001
- for five
years from the date of deregistration, however
- with
ASIC consent the company’s books and records may be destroyed six (6) months after the date of
deregistration (The liquidator’s application for ASIC consent is a part of our
standard procedures.)
- For the purpose of tax law – INCOME TAX ASSESSMENT ACT 1936 – SECT 262A
(please seek your own expert tax advice as to the interpretation of section
262A of the ITAA 1936)
- Only the Court may
order the ASIC to reinstate the company. Application to the Court to reinstate
the company is time consuming, costly and its outcome is uncertain.